No items found.
You are viewing the staging site, links to this site not to be shared publicly, use:
Production link

Problem Statement Repository: Atmospheric Methane Research

Atmospheric methane removal using engineered multimetallic catalysts

Atmospheric Methane Research problem statements are shared to build community and knowledge around key challenges to accelerate progress.

Submit a problem statementView all problem statements

Author(s)

Matteo Cargnello (Stanford University)


Published
July 15, 2024

Last Updated
July 25, 2024

This problem statement was submitted to the first round of the Exploratory Grants for Atmospheric Methane Research funding opportunity, and isn't endorsed, edited, or corrected by Spark.

Background Information

To hinder global temperature increase, regulations for greenhouse gas emissions targeting negative emission technologies are becoming more relevant. However, net-zero emissions alone cannot effectively limit increasing temperature.(1) Removal of gases other than CO2 can have synergistic effects. CH4 (Methane) removal is a promising process because CH4 is 25 times more potent than CO2 at trapping heat in the short term, and the removal of 1 g of CH4 can be as effective as the removal of 86 g of CO2 over 20 years.(2) Therefore, developing atmospheric CH4 removal technology, especially in combination with direct air capture efforts, can offer a new pathway to restore the atmosphere. Atmospheric CH4 concentration can be restored to pre-industrial levels by removing ~3.2 of the 5.3 Gt of CH4, which will result in reducing radiative forcing by ~16 %.(3)

Problem Articulation

Among various methods to remove CH4 from the atmosphere, thermal catalytic oxidation of CH4 (CH4 + 2O2 → CO2 + 2H2O) is being considered as one of the most promising technologies.(4) The savings in greenhouse gas potential are large in CO2 equivalents because converting 3.2Gt of CH4 only produces 3.2 Gt of CO2, much lower than the annual anthropogenic CO2 emissions (~40 Gt of CO2) (5) while eliminating a significant amount of total radiative forcing. Therefore, atmospheric CH4 removal using thermal catalytic oxidation could be a prominent technology and its feasibility needs to be studied. However, the temperature of operation can only be a few degrees above ambient temperature to make it feasible.(6) Current systems for atmospheric methane oxidation operate at temperatures >200 °C and require large amounts of catalyst. Finding cheap and abundant alternatives can be a breakthrough in this field. We found that palladium catalysts can oxidize nearly atmospheric methane streams at <150 °C.

We here propose to develop multimetallic catalysts for low-temperature oxidation of methane at atmospheric concentrations (2 ppm) using very low amounts of palladium and earth-abundant metals in a high-entropy alloy configuration to boost methane activation. We plan to understand and engineer the mechanism of methane activation at the lowest possible temperatures in 2 ppm methane to develop a feasible technology for atmospheric methane removal. We envision this catalyst to be coupled with direct air capture systems or operated alone with lowest energy input. More broadly, the fundamental knowledge of methane activation on earth-abundant materials can promote research in this area to develop catalysts that can achieve very low temperature performance to tackle atmospheric methane removal.

Impact Statement

Oxidation of CH4 requires thermal energy to break strong C-H bonds. To increase the energy efficiency of this reaction, catalysts are needed. Optimizing catalyst design while considering activity (temperature to fully convert CH4 to CO2) and stability (to water and poisoning byproducts) is crucial for developing a cost-effective and sustainable CH4 removal technology. In this project, we aim to develop highly active and stable catalysts based on our experience using palladium.(7) The main hypothesis driving this work is that by using very low loadings of palladium-based multimetallic catalysts (high-entropy alloys with 5 or more metals in a single particle), it is possible to increase the low-temperature activity of palladium while diluting it with cheap and abundant metals. A few scientific developments from our group support this hypothesis:

  1. By diluting Pt and Pd with cheap base metals, C-H activation rates increased by an order of magnitude;(8)
  2. Encapsulated metal particles within porous oxide layers showed increased activity (9-10) and stability;(11)
  3. High-entropy alloys that can decrease the overall amount of palladium while maintaining its high catalytic activity for methane oxidation were prepared by us. 

We therefore propose to develop palladium-based high-entropy alloy particles that are encapsulated within oxide layers for atmospheric methane oxidation. The overarching goal is to decrease the light-off temperature below 100 °C, with the opportunity to demonstrate feasibility for near-room temperature activity.

References

Additional Information

Provide feedback on problem statements

Related Problem Statements

Stay in touch

Sign up to our Spark newsletter and stay updated!

Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Methane Removal Community Newsletter signup